The Daily Californian
Note: May be incomplete: pages 1-2, 5-9, 11-16 missing.
This issue is also in the UC Berkeley Library's digital collections: see the library's copy.
Text of this issue
Transcribed automatically from the scanned pages, so it may contain errors, and columns may run together. The PDF above is the original.
New Boalt Hall Grading Plan:
Teachers', Students' Arguments
By ANDY MeGALL
Thus, a copy would be given to
Staff Writer
the student, and only the faculty,
The Boalt Hall faculty decision
administration or the
student
to throw out grades was not made
would be allowed to see it.
without a struggle - both among
For the large classes graded on
students and faculty.
the TML scale, comments would
According to Caleb Foote, pro-
not be practical, the committee
fessor of law and chairman of the
said, and thus not required unless
Curriculum Poliey committee that -
the instructor wished to say some-
suggested the unique plan adopt-
thing.
ed Tuesday night, some faculty
members still were and are op-
Faculty members against the
plan attacked it as irrational for
posed to the plan.
The plan, called the TML plan
forcing students into the stigma
for its division of students into a
of an "L" position and complained
Top 10 per cent, a Middle 80 per
the plan would actually
create
more work for professors, not
cent, and a Lower 10 per cent,
was passed by the faculty by a
three to one margin at a meeting
There was also some dissatis-
attended and participated in by
faction with the pressure the stu-
some 200 law
students
one
dents at the meeting put on the
quarter of the Boalt Hall student
faculty.
body. There were 27 of the ap
At the Tuesday meeting some
proximately 40 law faculty mem-
• 15 students spoke or read position
bers at the meeting.
papers in favor of the plan while
only two opposed it.
In smaller,
seminar
classes
Foote indicated there were two
where statistical TML evaluations
could not be
could be given an it fordent-
or three attempts to modify the
plan which were only narrowly
ors, a ¿Ạạ$p"
for passed, or a &U"
defeated before the faculty ap-
for
proved TML by a vote of 15-6.
unsatisfactory,iạiwhere the
They finally fell pretty much
student's work did not come up to
into lineịỊạồhe said.
minimum professional or schol
arly standards."
Foote, who admitted he found
The committee allowed for in-
the student involvement in the
dividual comment to help differ-
campaign for the plan "surpris-
entiate student work on the rec-
ing." said he thought it indicated
ord card. It suggested short com-
the increasingly apparent move-
ments such as almost a T," "bare
ment of the Boalt students "away
from traditional professional ca-
pass, or "outstanding."
These comments would be di-
reer aims towards changing soci-
ety through the law."
rected towards other schools or
prospecave empioyers, ine com-
He called the plan a product of
mittee recommended.
the four-faculty and two-student
For the H-P courses and indi-
member Curriculum Committee a
symbol of radical change."
Vidual 299 work, the committee
suggested instructors submit a
"They thought if they could get
written evaluation of the student's
the faculty to do this, they could
get more radical changes,"
work for educational purposes.
- ne
said.
The Curriculum Committee is
Daily Cal Staff
Positions Open
Application for positions zon
next year's Daily Californian staff
are now available from-the man-
aging desk, sixth floor of Eshle-
man Hall. All positions are open.
Completed applications must be
returned to the managing desk
no later than 5 p.m. Wednesday.
Appointments are made by the
11-member Daily Californian Pub-
lisher's Board and are based on
recommendations of the Senior
Editorial Board. For further in-
formation, see
the promotions
notice posted on the office bulle-
tin board.
currently
discussing
other
law
school innovations such as unit
credit for "clinical work, an in-
terdisciplinary program
leading
to an M.A. and a J.D. (Doctor, of
Jurisprudence) degree in four
years, and a greater emphasis on
individual work.
Clinical work. Foote explained,
would be work in legal aid socie-
ties and with the poor.
Steve Kroll, one of the two stu-
dent members on the Curriculum
Committee and thus one of the
few students in the University
community win a vote in educa
tional policy, attributed the plan
almost solely to student partici
pation in decision making.
ẠỊThe whole thing came about
(Continued on page 8)
Hearing Continues
On Race Charges
Testimony continued yesterday
at an open hearing of the Silver-
berg case.
Robert Silverberg, a black em-
ployee of the university in food
services, was suspended from his
job on February 27. According to
Miss Nellie True,
food service
manager for Unit 111, the suspen-
sion followed multiple infractions
including insubordination. Silver-
berg, however, contends discrimi-
nation played a part in his dis-
missal.
The hearing continues on Mon
day at 2:15 in 442 Stephens Hall.
A summary will be published at
its conclusion, expected in the
Ron & Mary insure cars
REPAIR
ELECTRIC
SHAVERS
ALL MAKES
ONE DAY SERVICE
Bancroft Shaver
Repair Center
SELL NEW ONES
SATHER GATE CENTER
2433:B Durant Ave
Free Parking with Validation
BASIC PUBLIC LIABILITY
for drivers with less than 3
single men
giris
married
$225 уг
221.
$197 yr
8123 vr 5107 yr
• $111
• RON & MARY LAI INSURE
PEOPLE, THEIR LIVES, HOMES & CARS
1474 Universitx..
Berkeley
841 1111
Friday, May 17, 1968
THE DAILY CALIFORNIAN
Page Three
Call for New Disciplinary Process
An Academic Senate committee
The Committee also expressed
The Academic Freedom Com
has recommended the establish-
concern with the present proce
mittee also raised objections to
ment of a new channel for adopt-
dures for contesting and inter-
some of the Commission's pro
ing and evaluating campus rules.
preting Regental policies and
posals. It expressed concern that
The Academic. Freedom Com-
rules. "Under present directions,
special
punishment might be
mittee made a preliminarys re-
such questions must be referred
port to the Academic Senate on
by the campus administration to
levied against students iwho un
proposals by the Study Commis-
successfully raise the issue
the General Counsel for decision,:
sion on University Governance
the report says.
rule invalidity after violations
have occurred."
for reform of campus rule making
"The net effect is to have de-
The Committee also expressed
and disciplinary procedures. It
cisions on student conduct on the
concern that confidential commu
said such a change is necessary
Berkeley campus made by the
nications by students to the Dean
because of the present "malfunc
General Counsel," the report con-
of Students office might be used
tioning of the Campus Rules
Committee.
cluded. This procedure, the com-
against a charged student. The
mittees said, is a violation of aca-
Committee also said it was dis
"It is clearly desirable to pro-
demic freedom.
pleased with a section of the re
vide an orderly channel whereby
The Committee also urged that
port which implies that punish
the Chancellor may be advised
the student standard of conduct,
ment can be imposed if a "pre-
about desirable changes originat-
recently released by University
ponderance*
ing with any member of the cam-
President Charles J. Hitch&Ạbe rè-
-or eviaence
against a charged student
is
pus community," the Committee
viewed to ensure that it does not
The present system requires
declared.
unduly inhibit protected or inno
Such a channel might be pro-
cent or desirable conduct.
that guilt be proved&Ạbeyond a
reasonable doubt."
vided by the Academic Senate,
the committee report suggested.
On disciplinary cases, the Com-
mittee said both the present sys
tem of handling them and the
Commission's proposalsiạiseem to
most of us 'compatible with our
strong.
traditions of academic
Of
freedomiẠại
The Academic Freedom Com-
mittee does not take a formal
stand on either system but is
pessimistic about the chances for
enactment of the Commission pro
posals. The latter proposals would
transfer final authority for stu-
dent diseipline from the Chan
cellor to an independent student-
jaculty judicial body.
The Academic Freedom Com
mittee's report discusses at length
possible changes in the present
system if the Study Commission's
University of California, Berkeley, Centennial Event
The Department of Music and the
Committee for Arts and Lectures present
The American Première
"L' ERISMENA"
A 17th Century Opera by Cavalli about the dangers
of Youth, Sex, Power & The Establishment
With an International Cast directed by Alan Curtis:
Staged by Holger Boland, of the Royal Danish Opera
Sets and Costumes by Ariel Parkinson
FRI., SAT. & SUN., MAY 17, 18 & 19
Hertz Hall, 8:30 p.m.
Tickets: $2.50 (Students $1.50). CAL & ASUC Box Offices.
CAL
recommendations are not imple-
mented andạẠạno other sweeping
change is made."
In addition to its recommenda-
tions concerning campus rules,
the Committee suggested that stu-
dent representatives to the Com
mittee on Student Conduct, which
presently handles most disciplin-
ary eases, be seleeted each vear
by an ASUC Committee on Com-
mittees rather than the Student
Judicial Committee.
ORE
The Academic Freedom Com-
mittee also recommended the es-
tablishment of subcommittees to
the Committee on Student Con-
duct to hear cases in open ses-
sions. Currently all hearings be-
fore the 11-man committee are
private.
Under the present system, open
a faculty hearing officer selected
from the full committee.
BULLETIN
Have YOU Bought
All Your BOOKS
for the SPRING QUARTER
We are returning Spring Quarter
Textbooks to make room for the
Summer Quarter stock.
SHOP BEFORE STOCK IS
REMOVED FROM THE
SHELVES.
STORE HOURS
Monday-Friday: 7:45 a.m. to 6:00 p.m
Saturday: 9:00 a.m. to 6:00 p.m.
Page Four
THE DAILY CALIFORNIAN
Friday, May 17, 1968
Poc-8 Conference Meet Opens Here Toddy
Field Splendor
POINT GETTIN' BEARS.
.. Mike Robinson (above), Cal's number one
pole vaulter, who has cleared 16 feet this season for the sixth best
Pac-8 jump, Gary Pennington (right), who holds the school record and
the fourth best conference javelin throw at 241'3i, and Bob Har-
greaves (far right), a 58' 7½" shotputter and also number four in the
league, prepare to meet the best today at the Pac-8 championships.
Robinson will be going against several others who have also clered
16 feet ond is expected to pick up at least a sixth place point. Pen-
nington has been picked to score well, as he will probably take
fourth, and Hargreoves is looking for a good put which might give
him the second spot.
Strong Bear Track Squad
Enters Pac-8 Championship
byy FRANK McDERMOTT
will come from Oregon State's
tion. UCLA's Don Domansky is
In a weekend of conference
Dick Fosbury.
The high-leaping
recovering from mid-season leg
championship meets all over the
Beaver cleared 7-1 indoors, but
trouble and should win. His team-
nation, the PAC-8 Championships
has been held to 6-10 outdoors.
mate Len Van Hofwegan is a
in Berkeley on Friday and Satur-
Paddy McCrary, the defending
tough, strong runner who should
day will be center stage. All the
conference champ in the 440 in-
give a good account of himself.
trials and the final of the 3000
termediate hurdles, will have the
Bob Hargreaves should be good
meter steeplechase will be held to.
battle of his life to retain his
day. beginning at 2:45 p.m. The
-for about a third in the shot put,
crown. Gary knoke,
- Oregon's
according to this reporter's dope
rest of the finals will take place
Australian import, has recorded a
sheet, off his fine 58.7½ put at
tomorrow, getting underway with
50.3 this year. And McCrary's old
Fresno last week.
the long jump at F:15 p.m.
nemesis,
The Bears, then, are not going
Among the athletes competing
stock, has clocked 51.1, to 51.5 for
here this weekend will be the in-
to take the track world by sur
the Cal senior.
prise, but they do have enough
door and outdoor world record
Pat Weddle and Larry Hengl,
SuIto make Some demen
holders in the pole vault, the world
the Bears' quaster-mile duo, will
teams work hard
record 440 relay quartet, the co-
be in some, pretty stiff competi-
places.
for
- higher
holder of the world high hurdle
record, and the co holder of the
world 100 meter mark. All but the
Northland Invaded
latter belong to USC. The sprint
standard is the property of Willie
Turner of Oregon State.
How does California fit into this
miniaturized Olympics? Well, this
reporter figures that Cal should
finish fifth in the conference. The
Trojans of USC would seem to
have the team title sewed up, with
Oregon and Oregon Stäte in a
fight to the finish for second, and
UCLA battling it out with the
Bears for fourth
High jumper Clarence Johnson
along with the mile relay team,
would seem to be two events
where Bears have the best chance
of taking top honors. Johnson will
he facing Stanford's Peter Boyce,
who has a 73 leap to his credit
this season. Johnson defeated the
Indian record holder in the Big
Meet this year.
Added competition for "Tree"
Daily Cal Sporta
Steve Mullenniex
Editor
Jim DeMartini
Night Editor
Asst. Editor
Bruce Jenkins
Cal Strokers Ready;
Indions Beware
by LARRY VAUGHN
respective heats. The JVs plied
their Oars one quarter length past
The California Varsity and
JV crews row today in the qualify.
Stanford last week, while the Var-
sity sunk under
ing heats of the annual Western
WO-WILDCO
Sprint Regatta held this year on
waves 200 meters from a hotly.
disputed second start.
Lake Seattle in Washington.
Both Bear eights-face Stanford
The Varsity boat is the same as
and three other crews in their
last week's with Russ Takei the
cox, Tayylor at stroke, Pat Stan-
ton No. 7, Bruce Robertson No. 6,
Jim Richards No. 5, Jerry Richard-
son No. 4, Steve Pierce No. 3, John
Hoofer No. 2, and Tom Tryon at
bow These oarsmen not onlv en-
ter the finals Saturday if they win
their heat, but they collect Stan-
ford shirts, because shirts were
held in lieu of the Sprints after
last Saturday's sinking and in-
decisive result.
The Junior Varsity boat is also
the same as last week with cox
Ken Kubota, stroke Bob People:
No. 7 Dwight Morgen, No. 6 Rie
Weakened
Cal Team to
Meet SF
This Saturday, the Cal Lacross
team will travel to San Francisco
to face the only team in their
league that they have beaten be-
fore.
However, Cal will be forced to .
play without their full team as the
entire
second midfield will be
benched. Usually Cal would run
three midfields, two experienced
and one inexperienced. However,
now. Cal will run one experienced
and one inexperienced, thus tak-
ing away much of Cal's scoring
punch.
The gam
will be played on the
Golden
Polo
field in San
Francisco at 2 p.m.
Glovers ot Oregon, Woshington
By BRUCE JENKINS
Wolfman will once
again use
son. He led the league in hitting
California kicks off a rugged six-
Bill Shinen behind the plate, as
last year (450) and is once again
game swing of the Northwest to-
he did in Los Angeles. Frank
over .400. Hanson has had a 17e
day with a 3 p.m. Pac-8 baseball
Smith had the job for a time, but
game hitting streak this year.
contest at the University of Ore-
hasn't seen action since the Stan-
Speaking of weak hitting. the
-gon.
ford game May 4.
Bears are now hitting 195 collec
The Bears, 49 in league and in
In Oregon, Cal will face a weak
tively in the Pacific-8, with no one
seventh place, will be in Corvallis
hitting team with good pitching.
-over
300. Bob Rebuschatis 15.
tomorow for a
doubleheader
The Ducks are 6-7 in league, and
against Oregon State. Following
have
two fine
pitchers,
Jon
closest at .293. but most of the
regulars aren't even over the .200
are a Monday doubleheader with
Wheeler and Mike Nicksic. Cal
Jevel.
Washington and a single game
may see Wheeler today, since
-The Bears have outscored their
against Washington State Tues
Coach Don Kirsch will want to
-opponents by one run, and made
da cal has already topped last
use him today and Tuesday.
less errors, but a lack of cluteh
-Oregon does have one outstand-
hitting has cost them numerous
year's " league
output
wins
ing hitter in shortstop Larry Han-
(three), but these trips North of-
one run ball games
Don Costello.
The Varsity has lost to UCLA
and Washington this season in
races in which the Blue and Gold
did not row up to their potential.
- ten prove disasterous. Stanford.
UCLA, and USC all in the thick
of the race-will also be visiting
the Oregon and Washington
teams
Six games in five days requires
starters, and-Coach George Wolf-
man has decided to 5o win b1n
Kirkpatrick today and. Tuesday
against Washington State
Kirkpatrick, considered to have
pro potential. has taken his lumps
on the mound, but he s also drawn
most of "the tough assignments.
Thus far Kirkpatrick is 6-8 over-
all.
• The Bears will be without the
ervices of thirdbaseman Don Wil
cox for at least three days. Wil-
It's All In the System
By THE MOTH
One might state that this method is BS but it's
Among the many cards and letters Moth has
received, Moth feels the following is of par
in tomorrow's Preakness, Moth looks to For-
ticular interest
ward pass to whip even a healthy Dancer's
Dear Mr. Moth,
Image. Some of the Kentucky Derby ạspeed'
By my computations, you have had four win
horses (Kentucky Sherry,
Gleaming Sword
ners and two seconds out of eight races, Please
have chosen not to run in the Preakness; thus
tell me the secret of your successful winning
with no one to push the early pace, Moth feels
ways.
Forward Pass will. have enough left to turn
(signed) Richard Nixon
back Dancer's Image stretch charge.
Golden Gate presents a handicap for babies
-the first major stakes race for two year olds
With 28 horses eligible, it's impossible to box"
cox became the first victim of
Evans Diamond's notoriously er-
ratic
infield Tuesday, when
ground ball struck him square in
the right eye.
can be summed up in one
found that the greener the feces, the more the
horse is ready to run.
To insure accuracy, Moth daily flys down to .
the stable area to see if any "sure thing ha
As a result, John Jackson wil
handle third base exclusively un
til Wilcex is ready. Dave Hagen
the regular secondbaseman, will
be his backup man
' Well, that's the secret of being a winner.
gests that you keep your eyes, on Pitch Out and
Single Point - colts that will hopefully race
in separate divisions. Pitch Out has run th
Point (out of Nashua) won easily in his only
start and could be "any kind of racehorse
HoW Samous
ON CHILE SENANT HE CAT
HOW NETTE SY COOMASH INNY
X33M
HIS 419
asino pure
MON
38079
N30109 S
WINES
HLIM
TELL LIA
OZOL
S:8 - 00
61 AoW 'Aopuns
parano a de one on ano
put tou pung on posan due sued
as an a de pop to sen
'suos
vara nonetodsuen Due popiond
ten you ree to saves
TUS!
or a on pas a count
pe quarano
Friday, May 17, 1968
THE DAILY CALIFORNIAN •
Page Seventeen
Vietnam Commencement
We will assemble in Sproul Plaza at 12:00 Noon. If we have won our court case we
will proceed from there to the Greek Thetre. We urge you to come promptly at
Noon. The ceremony at the Greek Theatre will begin at 12:40 ond will run ap-
proxim›tely one hour.
Program
Invocation: Rev. W. L. Herzfield, Lutheran Church, Missouri Synod.
Faculty Address: Prof. Charles Sellers, Professor of History.
Special Citations: Presented by Campus Draft Opposition to persons
who, by their conscientious refusal to the Selective Service System in
the face of enormous personal consequences, and by their steadfast
willingness to stand beside those who have refused, have made sig-
nificant commitments to the causes of peace and human liberty.
I. To Ronald Lockman, represented by his mother, Mrs. Vivian Wil-
liams. Citation to be presented by Larry Gerber, Class of '68.
II. To John Wells, represented by his sister, Judy Wells. Citation to
be presented by Steve Weiss, Class of '68.
III. To Christian and Sterling Hayden. Citation to be presented by
Orville Schell, Graduate in History.
Address: Dr. Robert Maynard Hutchins, Director of the Center for the
Study of Democratic Institutions.
Songs: Phil Ochs.
Student Address: Daniel Siegel, First-Year Student, Boalt Hall Law
School.
Exchange of Pledges: Led by Prof. Franz Schurmonn, Professor of His-
tory and Sociology.
Program Chairmon: Prof. Leon Wofsy, Professor of Immunology.
Music: Composed for the ceremony nd directed by Professor Michael Senturia.
proceedings will begin promptly arNoon. We urge you to come early.
Sponsored
* y CDO