The Daily Californian
Note: Fragment: only page 9 survives.
This issue is also in the UC Berkeley Library's digital collections: see the library's copy.
Text of this issue
Transcribed automatically from the scanned pages, so it may contain errors, and columns may run together. The PDF above is the original.
Tuesday, May 21, 1968
-THE DAILY CALIFORN
On Achieving the Highest Grade Point
'I Say to You, It Was Not Worth It'
By BRIAN McGUIRE
itself to such a mechanism as the grade point. More-
1 have been informed that I have the highest grade
over people at the University do not become subject
point average of any graduating senior in the College
to such an inhuman and impersonal judge of per-
of Letters and Science. The first thing I would like
formance.
to say to you is that it was not worth it.
For those of us tonight who think we are finally
My compulsive effort for a high grade point in my
through with the grade point game. I have a warn-
years at Berkeley contributed to an almost total alien-
ing. Those of us who are fortunate enough to go on
ation of myself from other people. When I was a
to graduate school this fall (and any male who goes
freshman here in 1964-65, I noticed that many stu-
to graduate school is quite fortunate these days) will
dents were reading Camus's novel The Stranger. I
find the same old system paralyzing any creativity.
read the book and found a part of myself in Meur-
If grade point is king among the Berkeley under-
sault. Like him I could not find within myself the
grads, it is also autocrat among the graduate students
power to participate in the values of the societies
Last. quarter 1 participated in a graduate seminar,
around me.
and I was shocked and disappointed to see all the
The Free Speech Movement totally confused me,
petty competition that existed at that level. The only
for I could not then understand the issues at stake.
difference is that in grad school, an "A" is an absolute
1 withdrew into the chambers of my own mind and
must, while as undergrads we have been allowed to
developed my own values. These personal standards
call the "B" an honor grade. Students in this seminar
were brutal, but they were mine.
The main thing
were asked to write a twenty page paper, and many
was to learn and to display that learning as well as
tried the chronic method of impressing the professor
possible to my teachers.
by overwhelming him with "magna opera
of forty
I became subject to a paralyzing mental machinery:
pages. Most professors are not impressed by quantity
if I did not study twelve hours a day, I was a failure.
alone, and yet the students keep up their hopes that
If I did not compose at the speed of a thousand words
the very weight of their effort will equalan "A."
an hour while writing a paper, I was a failure. If I
Removing the Mechanism
did not go through required reading at thirty-three
pages an hour or more, I was a failure. I pushed
This painfully laughable situation can be alleviated
by removing the punishment and reward mechanism
myself to maintan my quotas until I was more en-
of the grand university machine: the grade point. If
chained than a Russian factory worker in the 1930's.
this is done, There is some slight chance that Berkeley
The Lights in Windows
will provide to its students and faculty and even to its
Most of the time I acquiesced to my personal auto-
administration a better chance for personal encounter
cracy and tried to tell myself that I was doing the
only worthwhile thing there was for me to do: learn-
ing. Everything else seemed absurd and meaningless.
But at times I felt a revolt in myself, a desire for
more than printed pages and letter grades. The feel-
ing would come at night as I would be walking home
from the Library in Berkeley or in St. Andrews, where
I spent a year in Education Abroad. I would look at
the lights in the windows and think to myself: inside
those windows, close to those lights are people. Real,
BRIAN PATRICK McGUIRE
Possessor of the highest grade point average
of ony groduating senior in the College of Let-
ters and Science, McGuire declored his opposition
to the very system that gained him honor during
the initiation of new Phi Bet Kappa members
last week. After speaking with the aid of o few
notes ond much felling, he received o standing
ovation from the audience of 300 fellow key
holders. A history major, McGuire will attend
Oxford this fall.
on all levels of human contact. I hesitate to use such
a term.
"Personal encounter" is fast becoming a
cliché, but it is so popular in our vocabularies because
many people are realizing how much they need it.
Any classroom situation that does not make such en-
counter possible because of the number of students
should be questioned.
1 speak not only of the so-called liberal arts sub-
jects but also of the sciences, in which men are realiz-
ing more and more how few really cut and dried facts
live, human, fleshy, thinking, feeling, loving, despair-
there are and how many concepts have to be con-
ing people. I am out here and they are in there. They
stantly subjected to new definitions. This process of
will never come out here to me, and they would
word like "excellent" that is only
substitute-equiv-
never allow me to come inside to them.
alent for an "A." The advising sys
•dehnition requires fresh minds as well as trained ones
tem should be com-
but fresh minds loss their quality when they are asked
I can remember one night in the south of France
pletely overhauled so that students would be assigned
to do nothing but absorb.
at Arles last April, 1967. As I walked down a street.
to or would choose professors who would give per-.
I saw the warm lights of houses on one side of me
sonal evaluations of their work in their major fields.
It is so difficult in our own times to appeal to a
contemporary set of ideals that I am obliged to refer
and the blackness of the Rhône River on the other
This would put a tremendous burden on the depart-
side. I wanted to break down a door and say to an
ments and on the individual professors themselves.
you to a Greek idea of education. Socrates thought
that knowledge is implicit in us. We only need some-
astonished Frenchman, 'Je suis ici. C'est moi!. But
But it would provide a meaningful and thorough eval-
I kept on walking, and after a while the darkness and
uation of a student's work and replace some semi-
one to draw it out. When Socrates did so, he not
only taught men about ideas but also about them-
the secrets of the Rhône seemed far more inviting
arbitrary letter grade based on a ridiculous curve or
selves. And he linked the two-self and «dea.-in a
than the false welcome of the lights.
average. It is absurd to have one's effort in a course
synthesis that we in the twentieth century are almost
reduced to a letter or a percentage
Such experiences did not then lead me to the con-
incapable of making. In some areas of human life, the
clusions to which they are now bringing me. I thought
Time to Concentrate
High Middle Ages
in Western Europe achieved a
I could find happiness by perfecting my mental uni-
Outside the major field, courses would be taken
similar synthesis. Unable to cope with the futility
verse through total immersion in the learning process.
only on a pass-fail basis. Thus a French major would
of my own century. I have often looked to twelfth
Instead of encouraging me to form human bonds with
not be afraid to take Calculus, for there would be no
century writing on friendship for an ideal that I have
my fellow students, the grade-oriented system of the
more all-important grade point that might be brought
tried to incorporate and realize in my own life.
University of California made it possible and some-
down through the exploration of a different area of
We Eject Words
times comfortable for me to become caught up in the
knowledge. Also students would have more time to
prison of my mind.
concentrate on their major subjects. They would no
We have all heard the word "friendship" many times,
and we are constantly reminded of the chasm between
Those Awful Reading Rooms
longer be obliged to memorize uscless information in
ideal and real. And so we eject words like "friend-
I would like to verbalize an experience which many
courses taken only for an introduction to a subject
ship," "democracy," and "justice," from our vocabu-
of us have probably had here at Berkeley. Many times
and not for the acquisition of some quickly lost tech-
laries not because we do not want to believe in them
1 have sat in those awful undergraduate reading rooms,
nical knowledge.
tried to read a book, and found myself looking cur-
To some people it may seem
ironic that I am
but because our own personal realities we exclude
iously at someone's eyes or face or hands-or legs.
speaking of abolishing the venerated grade point to an
us from any honest belief in them. Trapped, we hold
our tongues in our bitterness and forget what it means
Presently the object of my eyes would somehow real-
audience that is being honoured for its high grade
to say what is really on our minds
ize he or she was being watched. As soon as the
point. It may seem that I am threatening such organ-
We, the first of the post-war babies, can only nod
other pair of eyes glances at mine, I flee back to my
izations as Phi Beta Kappa. Instead I am asking them
assent to Simon and Garfunkel for capturing our un-
ok. If it were only possible to smile or say 'hello,"
to return to the much less mechanical method through
articulated frustration in their "Sounds of Silence."
but an expression or a word would be totally mis-
which they used to select memb
on this campus.
I have been silent for almost four years, but now
understood. I have often had to remind myself that
A very good friend of, mine graduated from the Uni-
people in the reading rooms are really human beings.
versity of California in 1929 with almost all "A's,"
I am speaking to all of you. I should like to tell you
The atmosphere stifles human contact. In order to
but he never was elected to Phi Beta Kappa because
of a vision I had as a freshman, a vision that has
grown in my mind over the years, a vision which I
concentrate on imbibing books, we come together
he did the same thing I have done at Berkeley. He
am now prepared to share with you. I like to look at
into a tomb.
isolated himself in his studies and limited himself to
Thus far my remarks have been extremely negative.
few human contacts. My friend was not able to come
the Campanile, especially when it is floodlit at night.
My eyes reach up its ivory sides and join in its asser-
1 should like to be constructive now and to propose
into an intellectual brotherhood in the 1920's because,
a way that might enable students to concentrate less
for all his academic achievement, he had not found
tion of power, strength, and beauty. Everyone who
has taken psychology or anthropology knows what
on grades and more on the persons that they can
a way to share himself with other people. His elders
find in their professors, teaching assistants, and other a recognized the lack
the Campanile represents, but few of us can join in
in the University knew of him as a person, and they
its effort and move up with its promise in the direction
students. If more personal relationships could be
-of the stars.
formed at this University, learning would not be
The Grade, Point Game
eopardized but would be facilitated, for there would
But today in the University such contact between
be more intellectual, social, and personal dialogue be-
a student and older people outside the lecture room
tween persons and less cramming, shoving, and re-
is extraordinary. Personal relationships are usually
gurgitation of facts.
- limited to one's peer group. Each of us, trapped in
The entire University of California at Berkeley
our academic bags, has become a specialist in friend-
should follow the lead of the Santa Cruz campus and
ships as well as in studies. Phi Beta Kappa has be-
put all courses
on a pass-fail basis. Grades should
come since World War II a reward for a very narrow
be totally abolished, and they should not be replaced
kind of specialization in the grade point game. An or-
A Favored Place
The Campanile stands for the possibility of the Un-
iversity. The Campanile is fast becoming the bell tower
of the secular church in the modern world, a favored
place where men and women can come together to
exchange their ideas, participate in a liturgy and a
symbolism of experience that can be meaningful, and
give themselves to each other. The Campale car
be for us what the south tower of Chartres Cathedral
as has been done in some Eastern colleges, by à
ganization with such ideals does not need to prostitute